| 2000 | |
| Jamie Sallier '03 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| 2002 | |
| Beth Percy '04 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| 2003 | |
| Beth Percy '04 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| 2004 | |
| Beth Percy '04 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| 2005 | |
| Tori Hay '08 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| 2006 | |
| Esther Kovacs '08 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| 2007 | |
| Elizabeth Corman '07 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| Megan Kinney '08 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| Laura Montes '10 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| Sharada Strasmore '09 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| Sylvia Syracuse '09 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| 2008 | |
| Laura Montes '10 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| 2009 | |
| Christiana Butera '12 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| Laura Montes '10 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| 2010 | |
| Christiana Butera '12 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| Laura Montes '10 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| Jenna Swinkin '10 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| 2011 | |
| Christiana Butera '12 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| Rebecca Gordon '13 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| Kirsten Wendth '13 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| Rebecca Ercoli | U.S. Synchro Swimming Outstanding Collegiate Contributor Award |
| 2012 | |
| Christiana Butera '12 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| Rebecca Gordon '13 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| Kayla Moses '15 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| Kirsten Wendth '13 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| 2013 | |
| Nicole Chicoine '14 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| Kayla Moses '15 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| Kirsten Wendth '13 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| 2014 | |
| Nicole Chicoine '14 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| Kayla Moses '15 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| Emma Willing '17 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| 2015 | |
| Kayla Moses '15 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| Emma Willing '17 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| 2016 | |
| Emma Willing '17 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| Andreina Rojas '18 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| Margy Mackin '19 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| Gaby Eustache '19 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| 2018 | |
| Maxie Zimmerman '20 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| Margy Mackin '19 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| Tessa Lopresti '22 | U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate |
| Totals: 40 | |
| U.S. Synchro Swimming All-Collegiate (39) | |
| U.S. Synchro Swimming Outstanding Collegiate Contributor Award (1) |