| 1995-96 | |
| Christina Spinielli '98 | NEW 8 Academic All-Conference |
| Deborah Waldstein '97 | NEW 8 Academic All-Conference |
| 1999-00 | |
| Brea Walker '02 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| 2001-02 | |
| Rachel Fontaine '04 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Hillary Will '02 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| 2002-03 | |
| Nicole Bassaleh '05 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Rachel Fontaine '04 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Katie Levine '04 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Jessica Martin '04 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Blake Worrall '05 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| 2003-04 | |
| Rachel Fontaine '04 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Maura Huntington '06 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Katie Levine '04 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Blake Worrall '05 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| 2004-05 | |
| Kristen Behrens '07 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Cassie Bohn '07 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Jessie Haynes '05 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Maura Huntington '06 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Blake Worrall '05 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| 2005-06 | |
| Kristen Behrens '07 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Cassie Bohn '07 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Maura Huntington '06 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Abby Pratt '08 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| 2006-07 | |
| Kristen Behrens '07 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Cassie Bohn '07 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Caitlin Glover '09 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Abby Pratt '08 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| 2007-08 | |
| Caitlin Glover '09 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Iris Meehan '10 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Abby Pratt '08 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| 2008-09 | |
| Kathleen Dwyer '11 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Caitlin Glover '09 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Sara Hollar '11 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Iris Meehan '10 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Stephany Perkins '11 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| 2009-10 | |
| Kathleen Dwyer '11 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Sara Hollar '11 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Iris Meehan '10 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Stephany Perkins '11 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Alexandra Wilson '12 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| 2010-11 | |
| Kathleen Dwyer '11 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Sara Hollar '11 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Stephany Perkins '11 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Danica Piscetta '11 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Alexandra Wilson '12 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| 2011-12 | |
| Caroline Isaacs '13 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Alexandra Wilson '12 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| 2012-13 | |
| Caroline Isaacs '13 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Kelsey White '15 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| 2013-14 | |
| Helen Grant '16 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Abby Washington '16 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Kelsey White '15 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| 2014-15 | |
| Sydney Gillis '16 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Helen Grant '16 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Abby Washington '16 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Kelsey White '15 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| 2015-16 | |
| Rebecca Idman '16 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Jessica Ryabin '17 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Lucy Frey '18 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| 2016-17 | |
| Lucy Frey '18 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| 2017-18 | |
| Elizabeth Bernardy '20 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Hollis Cohan '20 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Caitlin Daley '20 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Lucy Frey '18 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Margaret Lawler '20 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Madeline Morrison '20 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Emily Reynolds '18 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Katherine Vitello '20 | NEWMAC Academic All-Conference |
| Totals: 68 | |
| NEW 8 Academic All-Conference (2) | |
| NEWMAC Academic All-Conference (66) |